4 Best Missouri True Crime Podcasts

1. The Toll

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
The Toll focuses on the effects a violent crime or traumatic event has on a family and community. Season 1 focuses on a cold case from Springfield, Missouri; the 1975 murder of 9-year-old Shirley Jane Rose. Our host, award winning journalist Nancy Simpson, interviews investigators and family members, taking the listener on a journey of what ends up being not just one, but many tragedies intertwined.MORE Producer/Network Nancy Simpson
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 364 Avg Length 26 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.Sign Up for Free with Email Continue with Google

2. Missing in Missouri

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
Missing in Missouri is an investigative podcast hosted by independent researchers Morgan and Zach Hicks. They investigate missing person cases exclusively in Missouri. Season 1 delves into the disappearance of Dana Bruce, 23, of Sedalia, MO.MORE Producer/Network Missing in Missouri
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 3.8/5Apple Reviews 24 Avg Length 29 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

3. Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!

Play
Apple Episodes
🎙️ Welcome to Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder!We're your hosts, Megan and Mindy — sisters, storytellers, retired educators, and lifelong lovers of true crime and all things mysterious. From chilling cold cases to strange small-town secrets, we'll dig deep into the stories that keep you up at night… especially the ones hiding right here in the heart of Missouri.Our podcast launched Fall 2025, and we are excited to take you on a journey through the twists, turns, and mayhem that make our state's history both fascinating and frightening.If you have a case or topic suggestion, please email the sisters at MORE Hosts Megan Owens, Mindy Johnson
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Recent Guests Faye Copeland, Ray Copeland
Apple Rating 5/5 Avg Length 45 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

4. The Paddlefish Caviar Heist

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
'Best True Crime Podcast' Nominee, 2023 AmbiesWarsaw, Missouri, is a small, rural town of just over 2,000 people in the American Midwest. Locally it's known as the 'quiet end of the Lake of the Ozarks.' Very few realize that it's the paddlefish capital of the world. But when a new group arrived driving flashy, imported cars and dropping hundreds of dollars on bait and tackle, the town became the setting for an undercover federal sting operation tasked with bringing down a suspected international caviar poaching ring. The Paddlefish Caviar Heist is a production of Imperative Entertainmen..MORE Producer/Network Imperative
Email ****@imperativeentertainment.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Apple Rating 3.9/5Apple Reviews 525Twitter 664 Avg Length 28 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact