9 Best New Jersey Crime Podcasts
New Jersey Crime Podcasts
Here are 9 Best New Jersey Crime Podcasts worth listening to in 2026.
Export Contact List1. Father Wants Us Dead
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
In 1971, a mild-mannered accountant and Sunday school teacher from New Jersey named John List murders his wife, mother and three children — only to disappear and begin a new life entirely on the other side of the country. Now, two veteran journalists go inside the mind of the killer, learn about the doomed family, and revisit the 18-year-quest to bring List to justice — a saga even more bizarre and twisted than ever previously reported. Check out our other podcasts: Someone's Hunting Us - The story of a serial killer you've never heard of and the women who took him down...more Hosts Rebecca Everett, Jessica Remo
Producer/Network NJ.com
Email ****@njadvancemedia.com
Location New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 3.7KFacebook 1.6MTwitter 534.9KInstagram 712.8K Avg Length 25 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.Sign Up for Free with Email Continue with Google
2. Dead End: Crime and Politics
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Dead End is where true crime meets political corruption. From the shocking murder of a politically connected couple to the unraveling of one of the most powerful figures in Washington, Season 2 exposes how power, ambition, and secrecy collide in New Jersey and beyond. In Season 1, we investigated the mysterious deaths of John and Joyce Sheridan, and the political machine connected to them. Now, we trace Senator Bob Menendez's rise and fall, and the romance and Egyptian spies at the center of his ruin. Episodes release every Tuesday.more Host Nancy Solomon
Producer/Network WNYC, Nancy Solomon
Email ****@wnyc.org
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Recent Guests Nadine Arslanian, Ron Chen +12 more
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 2.1KFacebook 21.9KTwitter 7.4KInstagram 6.9K Avg Length 22 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
3. Someone's Hunting Us
Play
Apple Episodes
In 2016, a serial killer was preying on Black women and girls he thought no one would miss — and getting away with it. Police in New Jersey never suspected that Khalil Wheeler-Weaver, a nerdy-looking, polite young man from a law enforcement family, was the one stalking the streets and dating apps for his next target.The journalists behind 'Father Wants Us Dead' — called one of the best true crime podcasts of all time by Entertainment Weekly — bring you a deeply-reported true crime story of a serial killer hiding in plain sight and the women who took him down. more Producer/Network NJ.com
Email ****@njadvancemedia.com
Location Montclair, New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 290 Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
4. In the Shadow of Princeton
Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
The matriarch of a prominent Princeton family is found stabbed to death in her locked basement in 1989. Why would anyone want to kill Cissy Stuart, one of the Ivy league town's most well-known characters? The shocking investigation sprawls across decades, as police turn their attention from a serial attacker, to her son, to a group of Princeton University students who said they were at a Grateful Dead concert at the time of the killing. The hot-blooded investigator sees a conspiracy...more Hosts Rebecca Everett, Kevin Shea
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@njadvancemedia.com
Location Princeton, New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 3.3/5Apple Reviews 441 Avg Length 33 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
5. DEVIL'S TEETH
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Beginning in Summer 1972, several young New Jersey women vanish while hitchhiking. All are later found dead in the woods miles away from home - and some of their bodies are allegedly found surrounded by strange and occult objects. Some locals fear a serial killer is on the loose. Others say a Satanic cult is to blame. Whispers of a police cover-up permeate the air.What really happened?Join author and Weird NJ correspondent Jesse P. Pollack as he chronicles a strange series of cold cases that still haunt the Garden State to this very day.more Host Jesse P. Pollack
Producer/Network 1289 Productions
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Springfield, New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 3.4/5Apple Reviews 218 Avg Length 24 min Format Medium form Since Dec 2015 Get Email Contact
6. NJ Criminal Podcast
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Welcome to New Jersey's favorite law podcast. NJ Criminal Podcast is the soapbox and megaphone for legal / lawyer / law-firm podcasting. Join us for NJ law discussions, series, and history. The best place to listen/watch is NJCriminalPodcast.com, where episodes are available by topic, guest, or chronologically. From cannabis legalization to the Lindbergh kidnapping trial, you're invited to listen, share, and rate the show at NJCriminalPodcast.com.more Host Meg McCormick Hoerner
Producer/Network Legal Podcasting
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Ocean City, New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 9Facebook 506Twitter 21 Avg Length 46 min Format Long form Since Mar 2020 Get Email Contact
7. The Garden State Parkway Murders
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Were Ted Bundy's first killings at the Jersey Shore? Hosted by Christian Barth, author of the book THE GARDEN STATE PARKWAY MURDERS: A COLD CASE MYSTERY, this podcast investigates the infamous serial killer's possible involvement in the brutal unsolved murders of college friends Susan Davis and Elizabeth Perry near Ocean City, New Jersey on Memorial Day 1969. Containing recorded interviews with possible witnesses, as well as newly discovered information on other suspects and persons of interest, the listener is asked to consider, Why hasn't this case been solved?more Producer/Network Christian Barth
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 9 Get Email Contact
8. Grim Tales from the Garden State
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
The New Jersey true crime podcast that dives into the murders, scams, and scandals all in the confines of the Garden StateNew episodes every other Friday!
Producer/Network Mrs. B
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 5 Avg Length 21 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
9. Absent Unknown Friend: The Rahway Murder
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
On a cold March night in 1887, a woman is tragically murdered in a small, prosperous New Jersey town. Over 135 years later her identity, and that of her killer, remain unknown. Join us as we delve deep into the mystery and try to give a woman back her name. Her death should not define her.more Producer/Network Absent Unknown Friend
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Rahway, New Jersey, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Recent Guest Dr. Alison Matthews David
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 3 Avg Length 35 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
No results found
Reset FiltersNew Jersey Crime shows hosts and producers
| Podcaster Name | Role | Podcast Link | Podcast Episodes | Gender | Location | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rebecca Everett | Co Host | fatherwantsusdead.com | 41 | Female | United States | |
| Jessica Remo | Co Host | fatherwantsusdead.com | 41 | Female | United States | |
| Nancy Solomon | Host | wnycstudios.org/podcasts/dead-end | 41 | Female | NJ, United States | |
| Rebecca Everett | Co Host | 20 | Female | United States | ||
| Kevin Shea | Co Host | 20 | Male | United States | ||
| Jesse P. Pollack | Host | spreaker.com/podcast/devil-s-teeth--4135394 | 23 | Male | Wellsville, NY, United States | |
| Meg McCormick Hoerner | Host | njcriminalpodcast.com | 210 | Female | Bridgeton, NJ, United States |