20 Best New York Fiction Podcasts

1. PodbyNight

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Stitch of Fate is a Vampire: The Masquerade TTRPG actual play.In this podcast, a coterie of vampires, known as the Drac Pack, navigate the politics of Kindred society and underground crime in modern-day New York City. Their dark pasts shadow the present as they try to solve a murder that happened in their domain.MORE Host Mike Martin
Producer/Network Pod by Night
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 201Facebook 562Twitter 2.2K Avg Length 92 min Format Extended Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.Sign Up for Free with Email Continue with Google

2. Fun City

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
A narrative play RPG podcast set in post-climate catastrophe New York City, in the year 2101. With Jenn de la Vega, Nick Guercio, Shannon Odell, and Bijan Stephen. GM'd by Mike Rugnetta with troublemaker Taylor Moore.MORE Hosts Jenn de la Vega, Mike Rugnetta, Bijan Stephen, Shannon Odell, Nick Guercio
Producer/Network Fun City Ventures LLC
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 188Twitter 1.8K Avg Length 82 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

3. Forgive Me!

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Forgive Me! tells the story of Father Ben, a try-hard young Catholic priest who was recently reassigned from Binghamton to St. Patrick's, a new parish in the fictional Texarkana, NY, under mysterious circumstances. Each episode follows Ben into the confessional with another eccentric parishioner from around town, exploring the intertwined lives of this new community and the funny, sad, and sometimes painful experiences that come out of the Catholic experience.MORE Producer/Network Rogue Dialogue
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Syracuse, New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 213Facebook 533Twitter 752Instagram 684 Avg Length 23 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

4. Overbrook

Play
Website Apple Spotify
Scenic nature parks home to unnatural occurrences. A cozy public library where the doors sometimes vanish. Residents that disappear for a bit and come back…different. In a small, (too) quiet town in upstate New York, a pair of friends juggle dodging horrors beyond imagination while navigating the all too tangible terror of adulthood. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.MORE Producer/Network Brainrot Presents
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 37Twitter 86 Avg Length 20 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

5. Tomorrow

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Annie Warbucks and Agatha Hannigan, two names forever connected by events that made one of them the richest girl in the world…and sent the other to prison. Tomorrow is an original, scripted series set in a post-pandemic New York City, five years after 'little orphan' Annie was adopted by billionaire Oliver Warbucks (Lance Reddick, The Wire, Fringe). Now 15, Annie (Abbie Grace Levi), a singer-songwriter/influencer extraordinaire, is about to face the biggest test of her signature positivity when a mystery rocks the Warbucks empire...MORE Producer/Network GZM Shows
Email ****@gzmshows.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 721Facebook 1.6KTwitter 1.1KInstagram 2.2K Avg Length 20 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

6. Toll Switch

Play
Website Apple Spotify
Toll Switch is a genre-jumping anthology series set in New York City in the 1950's. It's an odd urban vision that is revealed in an unorthodox way...through the telephone. Join the Operator as she patches you into the calls that light up her switchboard. She's deliberate and discerning, collecting and presenting to you only the rarest of exchanges. These conversations define a Manhattan where the possibilities not only defy limits, but also reason.MORE Producer/Network Toll Switch Studios
Email ****@tollswitchstudios.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 45Facebook 143Twitter 12 Avg Length 13 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

7. How to Win Friends and Disappear People

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Starring Leslie Grace and Soni Bringas, this 10-episode supernatural thriller follows Nancy (BRINGAS), a nebbish computer scientist, who becomes obsessed with her mysterious new neighbor. It doesn't take long for her to uncover a dark secret: the mystery woman, El (GRACE), is actually a centuries-old vampire. As Nancy becomes her familiar (basically her assistant), bringing the vampire into the social media-driven world of millennial New York City, they are both pulled down a rabbit hole of deceit, murder, and mayhem...MORE Host Sophia Lopez
Producer/Network QCODE
Email ****@qcodemedia.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 1.2KFacebook 2.3KTwitter 7.9KInstagram 24.7K Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

8. Deadly Ever After

Play
Website Apple Spotify
Deadly Ever After is a true crime parody podcast hosted by unhappily married couple Elizabeth and Harry recorded in their substandard home in Rochester, New York. Elizabeth dreams of the podcast becoming an overnight success but Harry's indifference to his wife's delusional aspirations and for the true crime genre in general causes friction between the couple and they often end up fighting viciously on-air.The information is real though the marriage, thankfully, is not...MORE Hosts Elizabeth Hickey, Harry Metcalf
Producer/Network Elizabeth Hickey & Harry Metcalf
Location Rochester, New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 20 Avg Length 48 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

9. Red Meat Village

Play
Website Apple Spotify
Destiny is missing. In the most dangerous neighborhood in New York City. The only men who can find her are private investigator Tony and the pro boxer who moonlights as his partner, Reggie. Destiny's sister, Lisa, asks Tony to find her, but clearly knows more about the situation than she lets on. Tony might not be the most impartial, because he's in love with Lisa, a married woman. And it all seems to be somehow connected to an underworld drug heist of cocaine worth millions...MORE Producer/Network Voyage Media
Email ****@voyagemedia.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 329Facebook 39.5KTwitter 816Instagram 22.9K Avg Length 16 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

10. Halcyon: The Book Of Paimon

Play
Website Apple Spotify
New York City, 1904. What appears to be a simple carnival and sideshow on the outskirts of Coney Island turns out to be much more than it seems to its latest addition to the carnival's close-knit family. Rooted in historical events, characters, and theology, Halcyon gives a unique perspective to the fantasy and horror genre. Dive deep into the mystical, the terrifying, and the unknown as the mysterious Professor Paimon offers you a contract you can't refuse... Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.MORE Producer/Network Paimon Media
Email ****@gmail.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 50Twitter 3 Avg Length 37 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

11. The House of Mirth

Play
Website Apple Spotify
A black comedy of manners about vast wealth and a woman who can define herself only through the perceptions of others. The beautiful Lily Bart lives among the nouveaux riches of New York City - people whose millions were made in railroads, shipping, land speculation and banking. In this morally and aesthetically bankrupt world, Lily, age twenty-nine, seeks a husband who can satisfy her cravings for endless admiration and all the trappings of wealth. But her quest comes to a scandalous end when she is accused of being the mistress of a wealthy man...MORE Producer/Network Edith Wharton
Email ****@mybooktoread.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Avg Length 26 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

12. Keen's Turn

Play
Website Spotify YouTube
Jared Stern is going to die. That is, unless he can slay a vampire before falling to his fangs…When an anxious altruist becomes chance witness to a vampire's murderous meal, he takes it upon himself to rid his city of the threat. But the vampire, not so easily defeated, takes an interest of his own in his would-be slayer.So join me, for a lively horror thriller, a tale of tricks and traps traversing New York City. This is Star Cross, book one.MORE Host Melaina Blanc
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Twitter 26Instagram 135 Avg Length 15 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

13. Good Morning, Monster

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Adapted from the book of the same name from NYT-bestselling author and therapist Catherine Gildiner, Good Morning, Monster follows the emotional recovery of Cathy's most heroic and memorable patients. In Season 1, Cathy is confronted by a powerful and determined man seeking help for his daughter. Cathy leaves home and comes out of early retirement to work with Madeline, a highly successful but emotionally broken New York City businesswoman whose mental health struggles are slowly destroying the company she worked to build.MORE Host Catherine Gildiner
Producer/Network Dear Media
Email ****@dearmedia.com
Location United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 341Facebook 50.4KInstagram 157.3K Avg Length 28 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

14. Broadway is my Beat: Crime in New York's Gritty Underworld

Play
Website Apple Spotify
'Broadway is my Beat' is a crime drama radio show that aired from 1949 to 1954. The series was created and produced by Elliott Lewis, who later became known as one of the best producers of radio drama. The show takes place in New York City and follows the cases of Detective Danny Clover, a hard-boiled detective who works the night shift on Broadway.The show's signature opening, with the deep, distinctive voice of Martin Gabel, is one of the most memorable in radio history...MORE Producer/Network SolvedMystery.com
Email ****@solvedmystery.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 2 Avg Length 30 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

15. Superhero: New York City - The Blue Beetle

Play
Website Apple Spotify
'The Blue Beetle' was a popular radio detective show that aired from 1940 to 1950. Created by Charles D. Strong, the series was broadcast on multiple radio networks and starred Frank Lovejoy as the masked crime-fighter, The Blue Beetle. The show was known for its thrilling action, colorful characters, and clever writing.Each episode of 'The Blue Beetle' followed the adventures of Dan Garrett, a rookie patrolman who discovers a mysterious scarab that gives him superhuman powers...MORE Producer/Network SolvedMystery.com
Email ****@solvedmystery.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 3 Avg Length 27 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

16. Sayonaraville

Play
Website Apple Spotify
In a magicked-up New York, resurrected spirit guardian Iris Penner and a rebooted Wild Hunt strive to prevent the End of Days. ...Two decades after a narrowly averted apocalypse, the world is threatened by eldritch-stoked climate disasters, a breakdown in general order, and proliferating interdimensional cracks. With no better answers, everyone has retreated deep into magic, regardless of the consequences. Iris Penner, who died fighting the averted apocalypse, has returned to life with a mission to prevent the next world-ending event...MORE Producer/Network Uncle Robot Media
Email ****@unclerobotmedia.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 5Facebook 17Twitter 39 Avg Length 47 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

17. King of the Egg Cream

Play
Website Apple Spotify
Based on the incredible true story of Harry Dolowich, who grew up poor in New York City during the Great Depression and got rich hatching a scheme to take over the one industry that wasn't already controlled by the Mob -- the chocolate syrup industry. Harry's ambition, charm and gift of gab can only take him so far when it turns out being a syrup racketeer ain't as sweet as it sounds...MORE Producer/Network Realm
Email ****@realm.fm
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 3.6/5Apple Reviews 64 Avg Length 22 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

18. The Lesser Dead

Play
Website Apple Spotify
THE LESSER DEAD is an immersive audio drama about a disparate group of vampires living in the wild-and-wooly world of 1978 New York City.  Our narrator Joey Peacock (Jack Kilmer) — an irreverent, eternally-young 19-year-old — introduces us to his unconventional family and its formidable leader, Margaret McMannis (Minnie Driver), who has built a home for all of them under the subways of the city. Margaret's strict rules have kept them safe and secure for decades... Until one night when Joey's discovery of three little kid vampires turns their world upside-down forever...MORE Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@echoverse.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 150Twitter 58 Avg Length 17 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

19. Rodriguez and Son episode 1

Play
Website Apple Spotify
A multi-ethnic, ensemble, sitcom style comedy about a Puerto Rican father and son who own a Botanica in Brooklyn New York. The Botanica is where everyone in the neighborhood hangs for gossip, magic potions, healing spells and just about anything else you need. Love problems…we've got a candle for that Good luck…we have a potion for that Revenge issues…we have a chant and a dead chicken for thatWe help people...The changing neighborhood is messing with the mojo of the old culture vs. the younger generation and changing times.Relax, laugh and enjoy a sitcom with a very Latin twist!MORE Host Mindy Rosario
Producer/Network Mindy Rosario
Email ****@yahoo.com
Location New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 1 Get Email Contact

20. Bad Influencer

Play Watch Video
Apple YouTube
A wannabe nobody makes a wish and wakes up a famous influencer only to find herself caught in non-stop scandals. Featuring Deuxmoi, Kristen Doute, Perez Hilton and Christy Carlson Romano, Bad Influencer is a romantic comedy for your ears set in the current New York City Influencer world. Supported by: First Round's On Me (FROME), a dating app for people who want to date intentionally and actually meet in person for a real date. First Round's On Me is now available for Android and iOS! Bring back real dating. Learn more: https://bit...MORE Producer/Network Emerald Audio Network
Email ****@gemini13media.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 311 Avg Length 22 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact