Podcasts like I Think Not

Jun 20, 2025⋅Contents
Follow Top Podcasts like I Think Not from one place on FeedSpot Reader
Looking for Podcasts Like I Think Not podcasters to listen to or for your outreach campaign to promote your brand or product? Our Podcasts Like I Think Not podcasters list is what you need.more When ranking these Podcasts Like I Think Not podcasts, we’ve considered not just their following, but also their engagement, ratings, reviews, freshness as well as overall influence in the Podcasts Like I Think Not space.Export full list with email contacts of hosts and booking agents in a spreadsheet or csv file.
Play All Episodes Follow All

1. Killer Fun Crime and Entertainment

Killer Fun Crime and Entertainment Follow
Apple Spotify
Hosts Christy Norman, Jackie Raimondi
Producer/Network Christy Norman
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 3.7/5Facebook 2.6KTwitter 367Instagram 169 Avg Length 67 min Why they are Similar Killer Fun Crime and Entertainment is like I Think Not! as both podcasts blend crime with humor, crafting an engaging experience by examining crime stories through a light-hearted lens. They explore different facets of crime, whether real or fictional, while maintaining a humorous, introspective approach. Co-host dynamics are central, offering listeners an entertaining yet thought-provoking take on crime narratives.
Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact Get Influential Podcasters ContactsGet access to 100k active Podcasters, Influencers in 1500 niche categories.(Export Full Database)Get targeted media contact list in your niche at your fingertips so you can focus on running your campaign.Email us the categories of Podcasters you want to reach out for your marketing campaign at anuj@feedspot.com Copy email. We'll share active Podcasters list with verified email contacts in an Excel or CSV format.

2. Morbid

Morbid Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Alaina Urquhart, Ash Kelley
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@morbid-podcast.com
Apple Rating 4.5/5Facebook 230.2KTwitter 126.4KInstagram 910.7K Avg Length 64 min Why they are Similar Both "Morbid" and "I Think Not!" intertwine true crime with humor, offering a refreshing take on grim subjects. Each podcast hosts a duo, blending well-researched narratives with comedic elements to provide an engaging experience. They also explore eerie tales and atypical crime stories, ensuring listeners are entertained while challenging conventional crime narratives through their unique storytelling styles.
Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact

3. Grits With a Side of Murder

Grits With a Side of Murder Follow
Website Apple Spotify
A true crime podcast (with a dash of humor and a splash of alcohol). Produced out of South Louisiana - covering crimes worldwide.
Host Tammy Meunier
Producer/Network Tammy and Friends
Email ****@gritswithasideofmurder.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 603Twitter 22Instagram 1.2K Avg Length 60 min Why they are Similar Grits With a Side of Murder is like I Think Not! because both podcasts blend true crime storytelling with humor, offering a unique and entertaining take on the genre. Each show infuses dramatic crime narratives with wit and levity, refreshing the conventional grim tales with comedic elements. This approach captivates audiences looking for both engaging crime stories and humorous commentary.
Get Email Contact

4. All Killa No Filla

All Killa No Filla Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Kiri Pritchard McLean, Rachel Fairburn
Producer/Network Kiri Pritchard - McLean
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 16.7KTwitter 15.1K Avg Length 61 min Since Oct 2014 Why they are Similar Both podcasts present true crime with a comedic twist, offering listeners a unique perspective on grim subjects. "I Think Not!" combines humor and keen critique to navigate true crime TV, while "All Killa No Filla" uses comedy to explore serial killers and criminal cases. The co-hosts of both podcasts expertly balance dark topics with humor, creating engaging narratives that appeal to true crime and comedy fans.
Get Email Contact

5. Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast

Killer Queens: A True Crime Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Tyrella Slemp, Tori Brothers
Producer/Network Killer Queens: A Light True Crime Podcast | QCODE
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 9.9KTwitter 980Instagram 25.5K Avg Length 59 min Since Aug 2017 Why they are Similar Both "Killer Queens" and "I Think Not!" are true crime podcasts that blend humor with crime storytelling, offering an entertaining perspective on otherwise grim tales. They share a unique approach to true crime, with "Killer Queens" incorporating 90's nostalgia and "I Think Not!" delivering campy critique. Both podcasts invite listeners into engaging narratives, striking a balance between light-heartedness and intriguing true crime details.
Get Email Contact

6. Which Murderer?

Which Murderer? Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Holly Gadd, Garry
Producer/Network Which Murderer
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.9/5Twitter 554Instagram 683 Avg Length 31 min Why they are Similar Both "Which Murderer?" and "I Think Not!" explore the true crime genre with engaging storytelling and a mix of humor and analysis. While "I Think Not!" emphasizes humor in its critique, "Which Murderer?" adds intrigue with debates and dark humor. Both podcasts transport listeners through intricate crime stories, focusing on unique perspectives, making them captivating for true crime enthusiasts.
Get Email Contact

7. Hitched 2 Homicide

Hitched 2 Homicide Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Kris Calvert, Rob Pottorf
Producer/Network Kris Calvert and Rob Pottorf
Email ****@hitched2homicide.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Facebook 380Twitter 67 Avg Length 68 min Since Mar 2020 Why they are Similar Both Hitched 2 Homicide and I Think Not! explore the fascinating realm of true crime, offering listeners engaging narratives that delve into murder and deception. While I Think Not! adds humor and critique through co-hosts Ellyn and Joey, Hitched 2 Homicide captivates with a Southern flair and deep dives by Kris and Heather. Both podcasts invite audiences to view crime stories from unique perspectives.
Get Email Contact

8. Murder and Moonshine

Murder and Moonshine Follow
Website Apple Spotify
A True Crime Podcast with a Southern Twist
Hosts Misty, Christy
Producer/Network Murder and Moonshine
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5 Avg Length 81 min Why they are Similar Both "Murder and Moonshine" and "I Think Not!" share a focus on true crime stories, offering unique perspectives and blending elements of culture, humor, and critique in their narratives. While "I Think Not!" incorporates humor and introspection within its storytelling, "Murder and Moonshine" provides a Southern cultural twist, both engaging listeners by reshaping the conventional narratives of true crime.
Get Email Contact

9. Crime in the Coalfields

Crime in the Coalfields Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Julia White, Harper Emch
Producer/Network Julia White and Harper Emch
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 157.1KTwitter 9.3KInstagram 9.3K Avg Length 29 min Why they are Similar Both "Crime in the Coalfields" and "I Think Not!" explore true crime stories, offering listeners a deep dive into unsettling narratives that often challenge mainstream portrayals. They each provide a unique regional or thematic focus—Appalachia's shadowy tales and the broader sphere of crime TV critiques—while emphasizing storytelling that captivates and provokes thought, shedding light on the darker aspects of crime.
Get Email Contact

10. Tell Me Mord

Tell Me Mord Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Melisa, Phuong Tran
Producer/Network Meli & Phuxi
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 5/5Instagram 15.1K Avg Length 70 min Why they are Similar Both Tell Me Mord and I Think Not! focus on the world of true crime, weaving humor into their narratives to provide engaging and thought-provoking perspectives. Each podcast uses a unique blend of storytelling and analysis, with their hosts diving into criminal cases with curiosity and critical examination. They both challenge conventional perceptions, making grim topics accessible and captivating for their listeners.
Get Email Contact

11. Juego De Asesinos Podcast

Juego De Asesinos Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Martha, Kiki
Producer/Network Juego De Asesinos Podcast
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.2/5 Avg Length 42 min Why they are Similar Both "Juego de Asesinos Podcast" and "I Think Not!" explore the realm of true crime with a blend of humor and storytelling that respects the gravity of the cases. They offer a unique narrative style that weaves humor with chilling tales, inviting listeners to engage with intricate stories while maintaining a light-hearted, introspective approach. Both podcasts create a compelling balance between intrigue and amusement, bringing fresh perspectives to the genre.
Get Email Contact

12. True Crime Reporter

True Crime Reporter Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Robert Riggs
Producer/Network Robert Riggs
Email ****@truecrimereporter.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 79Twitter 320Instagram 935 Avg Length 33 min Why they are Similar Both True Crime Reporter™ and I Think Not! immerse listeners in the world of true crime by exploring crime stories with a unique perspective. While True Crime Reporter™ engages through detailed storytelling led by an award-winning investigator, I Think Not! captivates with humor and critique, offering a fresh take on crime narratives. Both podcasts challenge conventional narratives, providing engaging and thought-provoking content.
Get Email Contact

13. Crime City Colorado: A True Crime Podcast

Crime City Colorado: A True Crime Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Cami Lynn, Kylie Marie
Producer/Network Cami Lynn and Kylie Marie
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.5/5Facebook 54 Avg Length 32 min Why they are Similar Both Crime City Colorado and I Think Not! share a unique approach to true crime by blending humor with their narratives, making grim stories more engaging. Both podcasts incorporate co-host dynamics, which add a blend of light-hearted banter and personal relationships to their storytelling. Additionally, they aim to provide thought-provoking perspectives while maintaining an entertaining and introspective atmosphere.
Get Email Contact

14. Murder Most Irish

Murder Most Irish Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
True Crime podcast based around cases from the little island of Ireland with feminism and some utter nonsense thrown in for good measure.
Hosts Sarah Jane, Emma McCormack
Producer/Network GoLoud
Email ****@goloudnow.com
Apple Rating 4.9/5Twitter 1.2KInstagram 7.5K Avg Length 76 min Why they are Similar Both "I Think Not!" and "Murder Most Irish" delve into the realm of true crime with a blend of humor and critical commentary, offering listeners a refreshing take on grim tales. They each incorporate humor and social insights, with "I Think Not!" providing a campy critique and "Murder Most Irish" integrating a feminist lens, offering nuanced perspectives that challenge conventional narratives.
Get Email Contact

15. Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia

Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Hailey, Holly
Producer/Network Hailey and Holly
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 3.7/5 Avg Length 40 min Why they are Similar Both "Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia" and "I Think Not!" delve into the realm of true crime, offering listeners an engaging exploration of chilling stories. They each provide unique narratives that blend conventional crime stories with additional elements, such as folklore and humorous critique, crafting an entertaining and thought-provoking experience that challenges conventional perspectives on crime.
Get Email Contact

16. Blood & Barrels

Blood & Barrels Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
A true crime comedy podcast that explores tales of crime & murder while indulging in local beer, wine & spirits. Laugh, gasp & raise a glass with us.
Hosts Mike, Amy
Producer/Network Blood & Barrels
Email ****@bloodandbarrels.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Facebook 169Twitter 22 Avg Length 71 min Why they are Similar Both "Blood & Barrels" and "I Think Not!" blend elements of true crime storytelling with humor, creating an engaging and entertaining podcast experience. They both explore crime narratives with a comedic twist, using humor to navigate and critique the darker aspects of society. The hosts in each podcast foster a lighthearted environment, allowing listeners to enjoy crime stories without the usual somber tone.
Get Email Contact

17. Psychopedia

Psychopedia Follow
Apple Spotify
Hosts Brooke Slater, Tank Sinatra
Producer/Network Tank Sinatra & Investigator Slater
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Instagram 87.4K Avg Length 68 min Why they are Similar Both podcasts uniquely blend true crime tales with humor, offering listeners a fresh take on the genre. Co-hosted by pairs with contrasting perspectives, both shows navigate the dark landscapes of crime with a captivating mix of curiosity and comedy. By involving humorous insights amid chilling tales, they ensure an engaging and thought-provoking experience that reshapes traditional true crime storytelling.
Get Email Contact

18. Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast

Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Fatina, Brii Wood
Producer/Network Stranger Danger: A True Crime Podcast
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Facebook 9.7KInstagram 1.8K Avg Length 69 min Why they are Similar Both Stranger Danger and I Think Not! are true crime podcasts that infuse humor into their exploration of crime stories, creating an engaging and entertaining experience for listeners. The hosts of both shows take an unconventional and playful approach to the often dark and grim subject of true crime, weaving humor and curiosity into their storytelling while offering fresh perspectives on unsettling tales.
Get Email Contact

19. True Crime Campfire

True Crime Campfire Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Katie, Whitney
Producer/Network True Crime Campfire
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 7.5KTwitter 1.6KInstagram 7.5K Avg Length 44 min Why they are Similar True Crime Campfire is akin to I Think Not! as both podcasts dive into the captivating realm of true crime with a mix of humor and thorough storytelling. Each show provides a fresh perspective on crime stories, weaving humor into grim narratives while exploring unusual cases and psychological intricacies. They engage listeners with dynamic hosts who inject levity into dark tales, offering an insightful and entertaining experience.
Get Email Contact

20. Murder & Magnolias

Murder & Magnolias Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Keith Morrison
Producer/Network Dateline NBC
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 2.6MTwitter 9.4MInstagram 455.6K Avg Length 4 min Why they are Similar Both podcasts explore the world of true crime through engaging storytelling. They delve into tales of crime and deception, highlighting contrasts between idyllic settings and sinister events. With charismatic hosts, they invite listeners to challenge traditional crime narratives and offer unique perspectives on mysteries, delivering entertainment infused with intrigue and discovery.
Get Email Contact

21. Carolina Crimes

Carolina Crimes Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Matt Hiers, Danielle Myers
Producer/Network Matt Hiers and Danielle Myers
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.9/5Twitter 691 Avg Length 48 min Why they are Similar Both "Carolina Crimes" and "I Think Not!" delve into the intriguing realm of true crime, captivating their audience with explorations of criminal cases and narratives. Each podcast offers its unique take; while "I Think Not!" blends humor and critique, "Carolina Crimes" focuses on deep historical insights. Both provide fresh perspectives on how crime impacts individuals and communities.
Get Email Contact

22. Lets Talk Murder | בואי נדבר רצח

Lets Talk Murder | בואי נדבר רצח Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Producer/Network שלי וקרן
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5 Avg Length 51 min Why they are Similar Both podcasts explore true crime stories with a focus on engaging their audiences through a combination of humor and analysis. They delve into human behavior connected with crime, offering new perspectives on infamous cases. Each features dynamic co-hosts who inject levity into dark topics, catering to listeners interested in both entertaining narratives and deeper psychological exploration.
Get Email Contact

23. True Crime on Easy Street

True Crime on Easy Street Follow
Website Apple Spotify
True crime podcast based in small town Alabama and hosted by a local team of experts.
Hosts Kelly Turner, Katy Givens, Scott Wright
Producer/Network True Crime on Easy Street, Bleav
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.9/5Facebook 823Twitter 246Instagram 421 Avg Length 58 min Why they are Similar Both "True Crime on Easy Street" and "I Think Not!" delve into the world of true crime, exploring complex narratives and uncovering hidden truths behind criminal tales. Each podcast offers a unique blend of investigation and storytelling, aiming to reshape listeners' perceptions of crime stories through engaging narratives. Their host-driven insights and intriguing content make them captivating listens for true crime enthusiasts.
Get Email Contact

24. Shaken and Disturbed

Shaken and Disturbed Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Daryn Carp, John Thrasher
Producer/Network John Thrasher and Daryn Carp
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Instagram 10.6K Avg Length 36 min Why they are Similar Both "Shaken and Disturbed" and "I Think Not!" blend true crime narratives with humor, offering listeners a fresh and engaging perspective. They transform grim stories into compelling entertainment, with insightful analysis and unique comedic flair. The hosts of both podcasts possess expertise in the genre and employ a style that intertwines humor with a deep exploration of crime stories.
Get Email Contact

25. True Crime All The Time

True Crime All The Time Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Mike Ferguson, Mike Gibson
Producer/Network Emash Digital / Wondery
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 57.7KTwitter 20.5KInstagram 42.2K Avg Length 68 min Why they are Similar Both "I Think Not!" and "True Crime All The Time" delve into the intricacies of true crime, engaging listeners with their unique storytelling styles. While "I Think Not!" incorporates humor and critique through hosts Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto, "True Crime All The Time" also offers a captivating analysis, blending serious discussions with wry wit through hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson, ensuring each podcast is both insightful and entertaining.
Get Email Contact

26. Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast

Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Mandy, Melissa Rice
Producer/Network Not Your Mom Media
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Facebook 21.5KTwitter 7.1KInstagram 33.8K Avg Length 55 min Why they are Similar Both "Moms and Mysteries" and "I Think Not!" are true-crime podcasts hosted by engaging co-hosts who blend humor and storytelling to explore crime narratives. They both invite listeners on a journey through various crime stories, offering unique perspectives and a mix of light and dark tones. Each podcast aims to engage the audience with humorous and thought-provoking insights into crime and justice.
Get Email Contact

27. Seeing Red A True Crime Podcast

Seeing Red A True Crime Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Mark Randell, Bethan Trueman
Producer/Network Seeing Red
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 3.5KInstagram 7.2K Avg Length 63 min Since Jul 2018 Why they are Similar Both "Seeing Red A True Crime Podcast" and "I Think Not!" delve into the realm of true crime, exploring the darker aspects of human behavior and criminal activity. They captivate audiences with compelling storytelling, blending humor and insight to provide fresh perspectives on the genre. Each podcast features charismatic hosts who guide listeners through chilling tales and thought-provoking narratives, ensuring a gripping experience.
Get Email Contact

28. Murder In The Rain

Murder In The Rain Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Emily Rowney, Alisha Holland, Josh McCullough
Producer/Network Murder In The Rain
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.3/5Facebook 2.6KTwitter 1.3KInstagram 6.9K Avg Length 51 min Since Apr 2019 Why they are Similar Both "Murder In The Rain" and "I Think Not!" share a focus on true crime, offering listeners an exploration of dark and mysterious narratives. Both podcasts bring forth a unique perspective on crime stories, with "Murder In The Rain" delving deeply into the psychological and historical aspects of the Pacific Northwest crimes, while "I Think Not!" infuses humor and critique to reshape the genre's conventional storytelling.
Get Email Contact

29. Morning Cup of Murder

Morning Cup of Murder Follow
Website Spotify
Host Korina Biemesderfer
Producer/Network Morning Cup of Murder
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 6.2KTwitter 766Instagram 4.9K Avg Length 13 min Since May 2019 Why they are Similar Morning Cup Of Murder and I Think Not! both immerse their audiences in the enthralling realm of true crime, albeit through distinct formats. They explore dark, intriguing stories that capture the imagination and probe the complexities of morality and crime. Each employs a unique storytelling approach—one with humor and critique, the other with succinct intensity—to engage listeners in thought-provoking narratives.
Get Email Contact

30. True Crime News: The Podcast

True Crime News: The Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Ana Garcia
Producer/Network True Crime News
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.2/5Facebook 2.3MTwitter 45.2KInstagram 197 Avg Length 46 min Since Feb 2011 Why they are Similar Both True Crime Daily The Podcast and I Think Not! delve into the world of true crime, exploring unsettling and grim stories. While each brings its unique style—True Crime Daily offering meticulous research and serious journalism, and I Think Not! infusing humor with insightful critiques—both podcasts capture the audience's interest by offering diverse perspectives on crime stories and their complex narratives.
Get Email Contact

31. The Misery Machine

The Misery Machine Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Producer/Network The Misery Machine
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 49.4KTwitter 1.8KInstagram 4.5K Avg Length 29 min Since Oct 2019 Why they are Similar The Misery Machine and I Think Not! both offer unique perspectives on true crime by diverging from traditional narratives. They challenge conventional storytelling through engaging hosts who infuse humor or intellectual depth. Each podcast critically examines societal influences and individual behaviors behind criminal acts, transforming typical crime stories into thought-provoking and entertaining journeys.
Get Email Contact

32. Terror Talk - Horror, True Crime and Humor

Terror Talk - Horror, True Crime and Humor Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Shannon Calder, Cathy Barrett
Producer/Network Shannon Calder | Catherine Barrett
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Twitter 257Instagram 515 Avg Length 24 min Since Nov 2018 Why they are Similar Both podcasts, "Terror Talk" and "I Think Not!", uniquely blend their subject matter with a distinctive use of humor, offering insightful discussions on dark and often taboo themes. They explore criminal psychology and true crime narratives with a fresh perspective, presenting listeners with an engaging mix of critical examination and entertainment while challenging traditional narratives surrounding crime and horror.
Get Email Contact

33. Life and Crimes with Andrew Rule

Life and Crimes with Andrew Rule Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Andrew Rule
Producer/Network Crime X
Email ****@news.com.au
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 49.3K Avg Length 34 min Since Aug 2017 Why they are Similar Both "Life and Crimes with Andrew Rule" and "I Think Not!" explore the intriguing realm of true crime, presenting stories that unravel the complexities of criminal events. They engage audiences by dissecting various aspects of crime, although "Life and Crimes" approaches with a more serious, investigative tone, while "I Think Not!" adds humor and a critical twist to conventional narratives.
Get Email Contact

34. True Crime Obsessed

True Crime Obsessed Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Patrick Hinds, Gillian Pensavalle
Producer/Network True Crime Obsessed
Email ****@truecrimeobsessed.com
Apple Rating 4.2/5Facebook 62.6KTwitter 3.8KInstagram 131.7K Avg Length 65 min Since May 2017 Why they are Similar Both "True Crime Obsessed" and "I Think Not!" offer a unique blend of true crime storytelling and humor, engaging listeners with a mix of thrilling narratives and comedic commentary. They both provide fresh, entertaining perspectives on crime documentaries and stories, challenging conventional narratives while maintaining a balance between the eerie and the light-hearted, leaving audiences eager for more.
Get Email Contact

35. Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Andrea Canning, Blayne Alexander, Josh Mankiewicz
Producer/Network Dateline NBC
Email ****@nbcuni.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 2.6MTwitter 9.4MInstagram 455.6K Avg Length 18 min Why they are Similar Both Dateline NBC and I Think Not! explore the world of true crime, offering listeners a deep dive into intricate and intriguing stories. While I Think Not! infuses humor and curiosity into its narratives, Dateline NBC delivers serious, suspenseful storytelling with a focus on human experiences. Together, they provide nuanced perspectives that both entertain and deepen the audience's understanding of true crime.
Get Email Contact

36. True Crime Bullsh**

True Crime Bullsh** Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Josh Hallmark
Producer/Network Studio BOTH/AND
Email ****@our-americana.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Twitter 3.2KInstagram 11.9K Avg Length 39 min Since Nov 2018 Why they are Similar Both "True Crime Bullsh" and "I Think Not!" explore the intricate world of true crime, each with a unique approach that captivates and engages. While "True Crime Bullsh" employs a serialized investigative method, "I Think Not!" blends humor and critique. Both podcasts delve into complex narratives, challenge conventional perceptions, and invite listeners to explore the darker aspects of human nature.
Get Email Contact

37. Talk Murder To Me

Talk Murder To Me Follow
Website Apple Spotify
We are true-crime at its finest.
Host Jonathan Harker
Producer/Network Talkocast
Email ****@talko.fm
Apple Rating 3.9/5Twitter 160 Avg Length 33 min Since May 2018 Why they are Similar Both "Talk Murder To Me" and "I Think Not!" explore the intricate world of true crime, taking listeners beyond standard narratives. Each podcast delves into complex cases, challenging conventional perceptions while incorporating unique storytelling. Though "I Think Not!" uses humor alongside its analysis, both podcasts push boundaries, offering listeners a riveting, thought-provoking dive into dark realities.
Get Email Contact

38. True Crime Never Sleeps

True Crime Never Sleeps Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Taking a deep dive into the world of true crime from serial killers to unsolved cold cases.
Host Larry Lease
Producer/Network True Crime Never Sleeps
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 3.7/5Facebook 5.8KTwitter 412Instagram 1.1K Avg Length 26 min Since Nov 2020 Why they are Similar True Crime Never Sleeps is like I Think Not! because both podcasts immerse listeners into the world of true crime with a captivating approach. While I Think Not! adds a humorous twist to its exploration, True Crime Never Sleeps focuses on raw and chilling storytelling. Both podcasts navigate murder and mystery, with each offering a unique perspective that engages and challenges traditional true crime narratives.
Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact

39. White Collars, Red Hands

White Collars, Red Hands Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Kishan Batcheldor, Nina Kern
Producer/Network White Collars, Red Hands
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 3.4/5Facebook 138Twitter 24Instagram 524 Avg Length 45 min Since Oct 2020 Why they are Similar Both podcasts cleverly combine elements of true crime with humor, offering entertaining and witty takes on typically serious subject matter. I Think Not! and White Collars, Red Hands present crime stories in a unique format that mixes investigation with comedic critique. This allows both podcast teams to engage listeners by reshaping conventional narratives and challenging the norms surrounding crime tales.
Get Email Contact

40. Reverie True Crime

Reverie True Crime Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Allison Williams, Maggie Damron
Producer/Network Paige Elmore
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 2.7KTwitter 16.4K Avg Length 59 min Why they are Similar Both "Reverie True Crime" and "I Think Not!" delve into the realm of true crime, exploring intricate tales of criminal acts and delving into the psychological aspects behind them. Both podcasts offer unique perspectives through engaging storytelling. While "I Think Not!" combines humor and critique, "Reverie True Crime" offers deep, authentic narratives, and each appeals to the audience's curiosity with their distinct styles.
Get Email Contact

41. Tapes from the Darkside | Crime & Psychology

Tapes from the Darkside | Crime & Psychology Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Tyler Zachary Borden
Producer/Network The Darkside | Premium
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5 Avg Length 53 min Why they are Similar Both "Tapes from the Darkside" and "I Think Not!" explore the fascinating and often grim world of true crime, providing listeners with engaging narratives that delve into complex criminal cases. While "Tapes from the Darkside" offers a methodical and immersive examination of single cases through genuine audio, "I Think Not!" infuses humor and critique as it challenges conventional crime narratives. Both podcasts stimulate thought and offer fresh perspectives on their subjects.
Get Email Contact

42. Loose Units: The Podcast

Loose Units: The Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Paul F. Verhoeven, John Verhoeven
Producer/Network Pillow Talk Productions
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5 Avg Length 29 min Since Dec 2018 Why they are Similar Loose Units and I Think Not! share similarities as both podcasts delve into the realm of true crime, offering unique perspectives on crime stories. They both incorporate humor and insightful critique into their narratives, making the often grim subject matter more engaging for listeners. Additionally, both podcasts are hosted by dynamic duos who provide fresh, thought-provoking takes on true crime, enhancing the genre's appeal.
Get Email Contact

43. True Crime Conversations

True Crime Conversations Follow
Website Apple Spotify
True Crime Conversations explores the stories and the people behind some of the world's most notorious crimes. 
Host Jessie Stephens
Producer/Network Mamamia
Email ****@mamamia.com.au
Apple Rating 4.5/5Facebook 1.4MTwitter 735Instagram 395.9K Avg Length 47 min Since Jun 2019 Why they are Similar True Crime Conversations is like I Think Not! because both podcasts delve into the intricate world of crime, focusing on unraveling complex crime stories and offering unique insights. While I Think Not! adds a humorous twist with co-hosts Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto, True Crime Conversations, hosted by Jessie Stephens, explores the psychological and societal aspects, creating engaging experiences for true crime enthusiasts.
Get Email Contact

Show 44 to 50