13 Best Underrated True Crime Podcasts

Listen to Top 13 Underrated True Crime Podcasts from one place on FeedSpot
The cases that rarely make headlines anchor this collection, where hosts dig into lesser-known and overlooked crime stories, often from small towns and forgotten victims, with careful research and respect. Made for true crime fans hungry for fresh mysteries they haven't already heard a dozen times.

Underrated True Crime Podcasts

Here are 13 Best Underrated True Crime Podcasts worth listening to in 2026.

Export Contact List

1. Obscura: A True Crime Podcast

Obscura: A True Crime Podcast
Apple Spotify Episodes
Host Justin Drown
Producer/Network Black Label
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 3.5KFacebook 8.8KTwitter 8.9KInstagram 4.7K Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Since Apr 2018 Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.

2. True Crime Couple

True Crime Couple
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Hosts Kay, John
Producer/Network True Crime Couple
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 3.3K Avg Length 98 min Format Extended Get Email Contact

3. Our True Crime Podcast

Our True Crime Podcast
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Hosts Jen, Cam
Producer/Network Our True Crime Podcast
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 1.6KTwitter 12.6K Avg Length 74 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

4. True Crime Kent

True Crime Kent
Apple Spotify Episodes
Host Kent Chungus
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 2.1K Avg Length 114 min Format Extended Get Email Contact

5. Already Gone Podcast

Already Gone Podcast
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Great Lakes. True Crime. Host Nina Innsted covers lesser-known cases from MICHIGAN and the Great Lakes Region. #TrueCrime #unsolved #Michigan
Host Nina Innsted
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 4.9KFacebook 10.8KInstagram 1.1K Avg Length 26 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

6. True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard

True Crime Cases You Haven't Heard
Apple Episodes
Producer/Network Steve Rhode | Host of the True Crime Podcast
Email ****@tapyournews.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 16 Avg Length 61 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

7. Murder In The Black

Murder In The Black
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Hosts Steph, Maia Bartee
Producer/Network Steph and M.D.
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 501 Avg Length 43 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

8. True Crime Unwind

True Crime Unwind
Apple Spotify Episodes
Producer/Network Kinsley & Mercedes
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 43 Avg Length 33 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

9. Crime on the Clarkfork

Crime on the Clarkfork
Apple Spotify Episodes
A true crime podcast that only covers cases that occurred in areas with populations of 15,000 or less. Small places, big crimes.
Producer/Network Mackenzie Spence
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 5 Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

10. SLO Crime, A True Crime Podcast

SLO Crime, A True Crime Podcast
Apple Spotify Episodes
SLO Crime explores lesser-known cases of murdered and/or missing people...and the often slow nature of justice. Hosted and written by Shoney Sien.
Host Shoney Sien
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.1/5Apple Reviews 9 Avg Length 25 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

11. Over the Horizon and Far Away

Over the Horizon and Far Away
Apple Spotify Episodes
True crime podcast focusing on the stories of people who are murdered or missing and received little media attention.
Producer/Network Over the Horizon and Far Away
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 7 Avg Length 23 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

12. Exploring Evil True Crime Reloaded

Exploring Evil True Crime Reloaded
Apple Spotify Episodes
Delve into the depths of depravity with lesser-known serial killer cases and unspeakable acts. Some bizarre. some twisted, all evil.
Producer/Network J.
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.1/5Apple Reviews 17 Avg Length 27 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

13. Obscure Crimes

Obscure Crimes
Apple Spotify Episodes
Producer/Network Anthony Okoye
Estimated listeners
Avg Length 10 min Format Bite size Get Email Contact

No results found

Reset Filters
Show 14 to 100

Underrated True Crime shows hosts and producers

Export full list with direct email contacts in a spreadsheet or csv file. Get Spreadsheet
Podcaster Name Email Role Podcast Link Podcast Episodes Gender
Justin Drown Host itsobscura.com 924 Male
Kay Co Host audioboom.com/channels/4914727-true-crime-couple 113 Female
John Co Host audioboom.com/channels/4914727-true-crime-couple 113 Male
Jen Co Host ourtruecrimepodcast.com 244 Female
Cam Co Host ourtruecrimepodcast.com 244 Male
Kent Chungus Host 129
Nina Innsted Host alreadygonepodcast.com 506 Female
Steph Co Host murderintheblack.com 268 Female
Maia Bartee Co Host murderintheblack.com 268 Female
Shoney Sien Host 104
Load 11 to 1000+ Podcasters