25 Best Unsolved Mysteries Podcasts

Follow Top 25 Unsolved Mysteries Podcasts from one place on FeedSpot Reader
Looking for Unsolved Mysteries podcasters to listen to or for your outreach campaign to promote your brand or product? Our Unsolved Mysteries podcasters list is what you need.more When ranking these Unsolved Mysteries podcasts, we’ve considered not just their following, but also their engagement, ratings, reviews, freshness as well as overall influence in the Unsolved Mysteries space.Export full list with email contacts of hosts and booking agents in a spreadsheet or csv file.

Unsolved Mysteries Podcasts

Here are 25 Best Unsolved Mysteries Podcasts worth listening to in 2025. Subscribe in one place on FeedSpot Reader.

Play All Episodes Follow All

1. Timesuck with Dan Cummins

Timesuck with Dan Cummins Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Dan Cummins
Producer/Network Dan Cummins
Email ****@dancummins.tv
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 56.7KTwitter 7.3KInstagram 78.3K Avg Length 127 min Get Email Contact Get Influential Podcasters ContactsGet access to 100k active Podcasters, Influencers in 1500 niche categories.(Export Full Database)Get targeted media contact list in your niche at your fingertips so you can focus on running your campaign.Email us the categories of Podcasters you want to reach out for your marketing campaign at anuj@feedspot.com Copy email. We'll share active Podcasters list with verified email contacts in an Excel or CSV format.

2. Red Web

Red Web Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Trevor Collins, Alfredo Diaz
Producer/Network Red Web
Email ****@roosterteeth.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 1.2MTwitter 31.7KInstagram 36.8K Avg Length 43 min Get Email Contact

3. Missing

Missing Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna
Producer/Network Crawlspace Media
Email ****@crawlspacepodcast.com
Apple Rating 3.7/5Facebook 20.5KTwitter 12.6KInstagram 7.6K Avg Length 67 min Get Email Contact

4. Crawlspace - True Crime & Mysteries

Crawlspace - True Crime & Mysteries Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Tim Pilleri, Lance Reenstierna, Jennifer Amell
Producer/Network Crawlspace Media
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.1/5Facebook 4.9KTwitter 6.3KInstagram 7.5K Avg Length 66 min Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact

5. Hillbilly Horror Stories Paranormal Podcast

Hillbilly Horror Stories Paranormal Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Jerry Paulley, Tracy Paulley
Producer/Network Jerry Paulley
Email ****@aol.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Twitter 6.3KInstagram 11.7K Avg Length 66 min Since Feb 2017 Get Email Contact

6. Sinisterhood

Sinisterhood Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Christie Wallace, Heather McKinney Brown
Producer/Network Audioboom Studios
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5 Avg Length 81 min Get Email Contact

7. Dark Histories

Dark Histories Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Fortnightly narratives on the unsolved and the unexplained, mysteries, historical true crime, touches of the paranormal and cultural peculiarities.
Host Ben Cutmore
Producer/Network Ben Cutmore
Email ****@darkhistories.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 3.4KTwitter 2.5KInstagram 6.4K Avg Length 52 min Since Jul 2017 Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact

8. Gone Cold - Texas True Crime

Gone Cold - Texas True Crime Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Vincent Strange
Producer/Network Gone Cold Productions
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 5.5KTwitter 10.2KInstagram 3.1K Avg Length 27 min Get Email Contact

9. Endless Thread

Endless Thread Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Benjamin Brock Johnson, Amory Sivertson
Producer/Network WBUR
Email ****@wbur.org
Apple Rating 4.1/5Twitter 2.4KInstagram 48.9K Avg Length 30 min Get Email Contact

10. Forgotten Australia

Forgotten Australia Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Topics covered History
Host Michael Adams
Producer/Network Forgotten Australia
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 6.2K Avg Length 43 min Get Email Contact

11. The Box of Oddities

The Box of Oddities Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Hosts Jethro Gilligan Toth, Katrina Walls
Producer/Network Airwave History
Email ****@theboxofoddities.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Twitter 1.5KInstagram 10.3K Avg Length 38 min Get Email Contact

12. The Trail Went Cold

The Trail Went Cold Follow
Apple Spotify
The Trail Went Cold is a true crime podcast where writer Robin Warder examines unsolved mysteries and offers his own theories as to what really happened.
Host Robin Warder
Producer/Network Robin Warder
Email ****@icloud.com
Apple Rating 4.5/5 Avg Length 50 min Get Email Contact

13. Web Crawlers

Web Crawlers Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Topics covered Entertainment News
Hosts Ali Segel, Melissa Stetten
Producer/Network Web Crawlers
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5 Avg Length 50 min Get Email Contact

14. The Generation Why Podcast

The Generation Why Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Hosts Aaron Habel, Justin Evans
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.5/5Facebook 30.6KTwitter 25.8KInstagram 39.4K Avg Length 43 min Get Email Contact

15. Lost Hills: Dark Canyon

Lost Hills: Dark Canyon Follow
Apple Spotify
Host Dana Goodyear
Producer/Network Pushkin
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.1/5 Avg Length 33 min Get Email Contact

16. The Conspirators Podcast

The Conspirators Podcast Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Nate Hale
Producer/Network The Conspirators Podcast
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Facebook 1.2KTwitter 2.8KInstagram 14K Avg Length 34 min Get Email Contact

17. Hollywood & Crime

Hollywood & Crime Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Tracy Pattin
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@wondery.com
Apple Rating 4.3/5 Avg Length 29 min Get Email Contact

18. Unsolved Murders: True Crime Stories

Unsolved Murders: True Crime Stories Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Carter Roy
Producer/Network Spotify Podcasts
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 47.6KTwitter 29.5KInstagram 79.4K Avg Length 42 min Get Email Contact

19. Unsolved Mysteries

Unsolved Mysteries Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
Host Steve French
Producer/Network Audacy
Email ****@unsolved.com
Apple Rating 4.7/5Facebook 260.1KTwitter 58.3KInstagram 67.1K Avg Length 27 min Since Jan 2021 Get Email Contact

20. LISK: Long Island Serial Killer

LISK: Long Island Serial Killer Follow
Apple Spotify
Host Chris Mass
Producer/Network Mopac Audio
Email ****@liskpodcast.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5Twitter 983Instagram 1.7K Avg Length 39 min Since Feb 2020 Get Email Contact

21. Death in Ice Valley

Death in Ice Valley Follow
Website Apple Spotify YouTube
An unidentified body. Who was she? Why hasn't she been missed? A BBC World Service and NRK original podcast, investigating a mystery unsolved for almost half a century.
Hosts Marit Higraff, Neil McCarthy
Producer/Network BBC World Service
Email ****@bbc.co.uk
Apple Rating 4.5/5 Avg Length 34 min Get Email Contact

22. Solvable by audiochuck

Solvable by audiochuck Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Producer/Network audiochuck
Email ****@audiochuck.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5Facebook 35.9KTwitter 9.4KInstagram 107.8K Avg Length 14 min Get Email Contact

23. True Crime Chronicles

True Crime Chronicles Follow
Website Apple Spotify
Host Reed Redmond
Producer/Network VAULT Studios
Email ****@tegna.com
Apple Rating 4.6/5Facebook 4.8K Avg Length 23 min Since May 2019 Get Email Contact

24. Back to Bardstown

Back to Bardstown Follow
Apple Spotify
Host Shay McAlister
Producer/Network VAULT Studios
Email ****@whas11.com
Apple Rating 4.4/5 Avg Length 27 min Get Email Contact

25. The Angel of Vine

The Angel of Vine Follow
Apple
Producer/Network iHeartPodcasts
Email ****@howstuffworks.com
Apple Rating 4.8/5 Avg Length 19 min Get Email Contact

Show 26 to 288

Unsolved Mysteries shows hosts and producers

Export full list with direct email contacts in a spreadsheet or csv file. Get Spreadsheet
Podcaster Name Email Role Podcast Link Twitter Handle Twitter Followers
Dan Cummins Host timesuck-with-dan-cummins.simplecast.com/episodes @d_cummins 22.8K
Trevor Collins Co Host roosterteeth.com/series/red-web @_trevorc 119.6K
Alfredo Diaz Co Host roosterteeth.com/series/red-web @alfredoplays 116.7K
Tim Pilleri Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/GLSS9533070472 @timpilleri 5.7K
Lance Reenstierna Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/GLSS9533070472 @lreenstierna 5.9K
Tim Pilleri Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/GLSS1898288411 @timpilleri 5.8K
Lance Reenstierna Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/GLSS1898288411 @lreenstierna 6K
Jennifer Amell Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/GLSS1898288411
Jerry Paulley Co Host hillbillyhorrorstories.com/podcast
Tracy Paulley Co Host hillbillyhorrorstories.com/podcast
Christie Wallace Co Host audioboom.com/channels/5093333-sinisterhood @christieorgtfo 2.3K
Heather McKinney Brown Co Host audioboom.com/channels/5093333-sinisterhood @mckvstheworld 3.4K
Ben Cutmore Host darkhistories.com @bmtcutmore 160
Vincent Strange Host spreaker.com/podcast/gone-cold-texas-true-crime--3203003
Benjamin Brock Johnson Co Host wbur.org/podcasts/endlessthread/archive @thebrockjohnson 7.2K
Amory Sivertson Co Host wbur.org/podcasts/endlessthread/archive @amorymusic 3.2K
Michael Adams Host forgottenaustralia.com
Jethro Gilligan Toth Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/ARML9966973519
Katrina Walls Co Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/ARML9966973519
Robin Warder Host @robin_warder 12.3K
Ali Segel Co Host instagram.com/webcrawlerspod/?hl=en @onlinealison 21.6K
Melissa Stetten Co Host instagram.com/webcrawlerspod/?hl=en @melissastetten 41.6K
Aaron Habel Co Host wondery.com/shows/generation-why @raasnio 2.1K
Justin Evans Co Host wondery.com/shows/generation-why
Dana Goodyear Host @danagoodyear 5.1K
Nate Hale Host theconspiratorspodcast.com/episodes @conspiratorcast 2.8K
Tracy Pattin Host wondery.com/shows/hollywood-and-crime
Carter Roy Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/END8394789342 @carterpaulyroy
Steve French Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/unsolved-mysteries @stevefrenchvo 1.7K
Chris Mass Host liskpodcast.com
Marit Higraff Co Host bbc.co.uk/programmes/p060ms2h/episodes/downloads @marithigraff 1.1K
Neil McCarthy Co Host bbc.co.uk/programmes/p060ms2h/episodes/downloads @neilmc999 103
Reed Redmond Host cms.megaphone.fm/channel/true-crime-chronicles
Shay McAlister Host @shaymcalistertv 6.6K
Load 35 to 1000+ Podcasters