24 Best US Mystery Podcasts

1. Murder, Mystery & Makeup

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Bailey Sarian, an award-winning true crime enthusiast, beauty influencer, and top content creator, brings to you her critically acclaimed podcast 'Murder, Mystery & Makeup!' From cannibals to serial killers, she dives deep into the darkest tales while blending in her passion for makeup artistry. Listed as a top podcast by global outlets like The Guardian , join Bailey on this thrilling journey. It'll be fun, we promise. Idk. lol.MORE Host Bailey Sarian
Producer/Network Audioboom Studios
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Los Angeles, California, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 10.7KFacebook 11.6MTwitter 411.1KInstagram 3M Avg Length 78 min Format Long form Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.Sign Up for Free with Email Continue with Google

2. Missing Persons Mysteries

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Welcome to Missing Persons Mysteries! Best Selling Author and Entertainment Icon Steve Stockton discuss Missing Persons Cases, True Paranormal Stories, Unsolved Mysteries, Missing 411 Cases, Unexplained Phenomenon, The Supernatural, True Crime, Bizarre and Unsolved Disappearances and Stories of Survival. 🎞️ Check out our YouTube channel! 🎉 Check out our Patreon for exclusive content! 🙌 Missing Persons Mysteries Podcast 🆕 Playlist with ALL the channels content Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/missing-persons-mysteries--5624803/support .MORE Host Steve Stockton
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Nashville, Tennessee, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.2/5Apple Reviews 373Facebook 14.8KTwitter 587Instagram 4.7K Avg Length 220 min Format Extended Get Email Contact

3. Appalachian Murder, Mystery And Legend

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Learn about the true Appalachian, mysteries, legends, murder & history as well as those stories outside Appalachia as viewed by a true Appalachian. I'm Larry Bentley and I was born and raised in the Appalachian mountains of southwest Virginia. I want to take you on a fantastic journey through the Appalachian mountains and beyond. We're going to explore everything from murder, native folklore and legend to true stories of hardship as seen through the watery eyes of an old Appalachian. Come join me. I guarantee it's not going to be anything like you think it is.MORE Host Larry Duane Bentley
Producer/Network Larry Bentley
Email ****@jhrudolph.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 37Twitter 23 Avg Length 13 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

4. Old Time Radio Mystery, Suspense, & Horror

Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
OTR Mystery, Suspense, & Horror is a podcast dedicated to exploring, analyzing, commentating and critiqing old time radio programs and plays that fall into the genre of mystery, suspense, & horror.MORE Host Dakoda Black
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.4/5Apple Reviews 791 Avg Length 30 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

5. Ohio Mysteries

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Each week Ohio Mysteries explores unsolved murders, lost shipwrecks, local legends and more! https://www.ohiomysteries.com. https://www.facebook.com/ohiomysteries https://www.patreon.com/ohiomysteries https://www.twitter.com/mysteriesohioIn any given episode we feature fantastic music by the following music-https://soundcloud.com/davidhydemusic...MORE Hosts Stephen, Paula
Email ****@ohiomysteries.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 290Facebook 11.7KTwitter 448Instagram 681 Avg Length 26 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

6. Murder and Mystery in the Last Frontier

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Listen to tales of true murder and mystery in Alaska.
Host Robin Barefield
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Kodiak, Alaska, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.7/5Apple Reviews 207Facebook 147Twitter 243Instagram 4.5K Avg Length 27 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

7. Southern Mysteries Podcast

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Unearthing the forgotten, the mysterious, and the legendary—one Southern story at a time. Hosted by Shannon Ballard, Southern Mysteries explores the rich and often untold history of the American South through a captivating mix of folklore, legends, unexplained mysteries, and true crime. Each episode uncovers a compelling tale from a Southern state, blending history with intrigue to reveal the fascinating stories that time left behind...MORE Host Shannon Ballard
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 948Facebook 2.2KInstagram 706 Avg Length 28 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

8. Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia

Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Welcome to Mountain Mysteries: Tales from Appalachia, a true crime podcast hosted by Holly and Hailey. Join us each week as we dive into murders, missing persons cases, and other spooky and paranormal happenings in the mountains of Appalachia.MORE Hosts Hailey, Holly
Producer/Network Hailey and Holly
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 3.7/5Apple Reviews 131 Avg Length 38 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

9. Mystery to Me

Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Mystery to Me is a brand new podcast hosted by Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee. We're fans of all things mystery. Mystery to Me will feature us riffing on murder mysteries, film noir, cozy detective stories, police procedurals, psychological thrillers, legal dramas, tales of teen sleuths, and more. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. And send your own recommendations on what to watch to ****@gmail.com. Stay mysterious! Mystery to Me is a production of Mystery Sheet LLC.MORE Hosts Áine Cain, Kevin Greenlee
Producer/Network Mystery Sheet
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 3.7/5Apple Reviews 18Facebook 16Twitter 79Instagram 222 Avg Length 36 min Format Medium form Since Jan 2021 Get Email Contact

10. Scary Mysteries

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
True Crime News and Creepy Compilations, Scary Mysteries covers all the weird stories you want to hear. And if you like us then check out our other podcast called EVERY TOWN. Because Every Town, has a dark side. https://open.spotify.com/show/4K2gvVKzxlEx636qMFSoojHosted by: Andrew Fitzgerald? Watch This Episode On Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/scarymysteries? Check out our movie AN ANGRY BOY for FREE!https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvtlOlODQ8g&t=5238shttps://tubitv.com/movies/100029672/an-angry-boyInternational & Other Ways To Watch: https://www.anangryboy.com/? MERCH: https://scary-mysteries.teemill.com/? Free 7 Day Trail on Exclusive Episodes, Podcasts & Perks! https://www.patreon.com/scarymysteries? X: ..MORE Host Andrew Fitzgerald
Producer/Network Scary Mysteries
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 1.3KFacebook 181.4KInstagram 1K Avg Length 29 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

11. Unsolved Mysteries Rewind

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
...doing the research so you don't have to...Come along as two friends get together to discuss episodes of their (and your) favorite television show, Unsolved Mysteries!
Hosts Mark, Catharine
Producer/Network Unsolved Mysteries Rewind
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 3.5/5Apple Reviews 170Twitter 169 Avg Length 54 min Format Long form Since May 2020 Get Email Contact

12. Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil

Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Dr. Phil McGraw takes an in-depth look at true crime cases, mysteries and provides his in-depth analysis.
Host Dr. Phil McGraw
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.2/5Apple Reviews 12KFacebook 30.3KTwitter 8.5KInstagram 36.7K Avg Length 48 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

13. Great Crime & Mystery Books

Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
100 Great Crime and Mystery Books!
Producer/Network Crime Audiobooks
Email ****@awpodcast.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 20 Avg Length 63 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

14. Mystery Archives Episodes

Play Watch Video
Website Apple YouTube Episodes
Welcome to Mystery Archives — Your Source for Paranormal Stories and Haunting Mysteries!On Mystery Archives, we dive deep into eerie paranormal cases, ghostly encounters, and unsolved mysteries. Our documentary-style videos uncover chilling details and theories behind the world's most terrifying hauntings, haunted locations, and unexplained phenomena. Become a Paid Subscriber: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/mystery-archives-episodes/subscribeMORE Producer/Network Mystery Archives Episodes
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.8/5Apple Reviews 58Facebook 61.6KInstagram 680 Avg Length 139 min Format Extended Get Email Contact

15. Unexplained Mysteries

Play Watch Video
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Life can take unexpected turns. Some are easily defined. Others… require further investigation. Every Tuesday, collect the pieces of a seemingly unsolvable puzzle — events in history which have eluded so many for so long, but deserve a deeper look. Unexplained Mysteries is a Spotify Original.MORE Hosts Molly Brandenburg, Richard Rossner
Producer/Network Spotify Podcasts
Email ****@parcast.com
Location New York City, New York, United States
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 7.5KFacebook 51.1KTwitter 28.8KInstagram 94.7K Avg Length 70 min Format Long form Since Feb 2018 Get Email Contact

16. Zachsolved Mysteries

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
We solve the mysteries that Unsolved Mysteries couldn't solve! Stephanie, Keeper of Mysteries, regales you with sordid tales from TV's Unsolved Mysteries, while Super Sleuth Zach applies his keen detective skills to crack each case. This isn't your standard recap podcast - our unscripted banter leads you down surprising tangents, mixing humor with genuine discussion about mental health and life's bigger questions. Stephanie's centered presence perfectly balances Zach's rough-around-the-edges approach, creating a unique blend of the bawdy and the profound...MORE Producer/Network Zach and Stephanie
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 63 Avg Length 73 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

17. The Mystery Hole Podcast

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
unhinged discussions of a new mystery each episode. you'll be dumber for listening.
Producer/Network laneblevins01
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 42 Avg Length 65 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

18. Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!

Play
Apple Episodes
🎙️ Welcome to Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder!We're your hosts, Megan and Mindy — sisters, storytellers, retired educators, and lifelong lovers of true crime and all things mysterious. From chilling cold cases to strange small-town secrets, we'll dig deep into the stories that keep you up at night… especially the ones hiding right here in the heart of Missouri.Our podcast launched Fall 2025, and we are excited to take you on a journey through the twists, turns, and mayhem that make our state's history both fascinating and frightening.If you have a case or topic suggestion, please email the sisters at MORE Hosts Megan Owens, Mindy Johnson
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5 Avg Length 44 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

19. Mystery - OTNetcast.com

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
Mystery is a fiction genre where the nature of an event, usually a murder or other crime, remains mysterious until the end of the story. Often within a closed circle of suspects, each suspect is usually provided with a credible motive and a reasonable opportunity for committing the crime. The central character is often a detective (such as Sherlock Holmes), who eventually solves the mystery by logical deduction from facts presented to the reader. Some mystery books are non-fiction...MORE Host Andrew Rhynes
Producer/Network Old Time Netcast
Email ****@otrwesterns.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 68 Avg Length 32 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

20. Cold Blooded: Mystery in Alaska

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
In the remote town of Ketchikan, Alaska, a beloved doctor is found dead in his home. At first, investigators think he died from a heart attack or by suicide. But when police take a closer look at the scene, clues point to something more ominous: Was Dr. Eric Garcia murdered?In 'Cold Blooded: Mystery in Alaska,' Ketchikan police uncover a secret romance, the theft of hundreds of thousands of dollars in property, and a suspicious character with ties to the porn industry.MORE Host Chris Connelly
Email ****@abc.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.2/5 Avg Length 28 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

21. WILD Mysteries

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
Welcome to WILD Mysteries! Investigate nature's marvelous mysteries with your hosts Lauren and Laura. Each episode investigates the unique story of a really WILD animal, plant, or place around the world. From remarkable rodents to nifty nests and everything in between, solve these mysteries with us while you eat your breakfast, run errands, or enjoy your morning time rhythm. Fostering connection to nature and critical thinking skills, the WILD Mysteries podcast is good, old-fashioned family fun...MORE Producer/Network WILD Mysteries Team
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 4.9/5Apple Reviews 27 Avg Length 14 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

22. The Mystery

Play
Apple Episodes
A family-friendly mystery podcast who involves the listeners in the mystery. After the episode, join our Remind group by texting @mystery95 to 81010 and text in your guess. If you're right, you just might become part of the mystery yourself — with an episode written about you.MORE Hosts Jenson Day, Marleigh Solomon
Email ****@jensonday.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5 Avg Length 7 min Format Bite size Get Email Contact

23. PAINT BY MURDERS - a Harrisburg Homicide Mystery

Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
Paint by Murders is an original, as of yet unpublished, mystery novel. It is the first in a series of Harrisburg Homicides. It is written, hosted, and narrated by M. Travis DiNicola. Overview: The Capital city and its art galleries, bars, restaurants, and long-held secrets are featured in this cozy- inspired mystery that is as unpredictable as the mighty Susquehanna River it sits on. When painter Keith Reed stumbles across a dead body in a Harrisburg bookstore, he doesn't yet know that the victim was bludgeoned with an autographed brick once used in a work by the internationally famous 'bad boy' artist Alan Moonshine...MORE Host M. Travis DiNicola
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 24 Avg Length 25 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

24. History and Mystery in Kansas City

Spotify
Have you ever wondered about the old creepy abandoned buildings in your city? Or heard rumors about creatures lurking in the night in your neighborhood? Maybe your city is plagued by ghosts or serial killers and you want to know more. Do you want to know what makes your city unique, learn about its dirty history, and its attractions? Then History and Mystery in Kansas City is the podcast for you. We will explore those topics for Kansas City and the surrounding areas. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.MORE Hosts Laura Bilecki, Tahlia Isojoki
Email ****@gmail.com
Estimated listeners
Get Email Contact