15 Best Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts

Listen to Top 15 Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts from one place on FeedSpot
Looking for Wisconsin True Crime podcasts to listen to or for your outreach campaign to promote your brand or product? Our Wisconsin True Crime podcasts list is what you need. When ranking these Wisconsin True Crime podcasts, we've considered not just their following, but also their engagement, ratings, reviews, listener counts, freshness as well as overall influence in the Wisconsin True Crime space. more less

Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts

Here are 15 Best Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts worth listening to in 2026.

Export Contact List

1. Badger Bizarre

Badger Bizarre
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
True crime, unsolved mysteries, paranormal tales and bizarre happenings in the state of Wisconsin.
Hosts Scott Wittman, Mickey Sanders
Email ****@att.net
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Recent Guests Charlotte Lamb, Otis Redding +1 more
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 49Facebook 1.8KTwitter 47 Avg Length 118 min Format Extended Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.

2. Run, Bambi, Run

Run, Bambi, Run
Apple Spotify Episodes
Host Vanessa Grigoriadis
Producer/Network Apple TV / Campside Media
Email ****@mac.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 4.4/5Apple Reviews 1.7K Avg Length 24 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

3. Milwaukee Mafia

Milwaukee Mafia
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Host Gavin Schmitt
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Recent Guests Sid Ceasar, John Balistreri +2 more
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 48Facebook 775 Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

4. Unsolved: A murder mystery podcast

Unsolved: A murder mystery podcast
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Host Gina Barton
Producer/Network USA TODAY and Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Email ****@gannett.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 4/5Apple Reviews 930Facebook 10.5MTwitter 5.1MInstagram 3.8M Avg Length 23 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

5. MANslaughter

MANslaughter
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Host Dorothy Marcic
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@wondery.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 3.3/5Apple Reviews 1.6KFacebook 165.4KTwitter 107.1KInstagram 196.2K Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

6. Cold Case: Frozen Tundra

Cold Case: Frozen Tundra
Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Producer/Network Dogfish Stingray Media
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 179 Avg Length 35 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

7. Severed Affair: The Gruesome Murder of Shad Thyrion

Severed Affair: The Gruesome Murder of Shad Thyrion
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Producer/Network Law&Crime
Email ****@lawandcrime.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 3.6/5Apple Reviews 335Facebook 5.7MTwitter 141K Avg Length 30 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

8. Fox Cities Murder & Mayhem

Fox Cities Murder & Mayhem
Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Hosts Gavin Schmitt, Eric Wulterkens
Producer/Network Gavin Schmitt
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 7Facebook 775 Avg Length 38 min Format Medium form Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact

9. My Cousin Augie

My Cousin Augie
Apple Spotify Episodes
Producer/Network Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Email ****@gannett.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 25 Avg Length 27 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

10. True Crime Wisconsin

True Crime Wisconsin
Apple Episodes
Producer/Network WMTV
Email ****@wmtv15news.com
Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

11. Ope, it's Murder

Ope, it's Murder
Apple Episodes
Midwest roots. Dark stories. Strong coffee. Two best friends uncovering Wisconsin and Midwest true crime, one cup at a time.
Producer/Network Lindsey and Libbie
Email ****@opeitsmurder.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 3 Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

12. Dark Matter Moms

Dark Matter Moms
Apple Episodes
Producer/Network Dark Matter Moms
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 1 Avg Length 53 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

13. Wisconsin Cold Cases Podcast

Wisconsin Cold Cases Podcast
Website Spotify YouTube Episodes
Every month, join WSAW's Kassandra Sepeda as she takes a deeper, investigative look into the often forgotten cold cases and missing people in central Wisconsin.
Host Kassandra Sepeda
Email ****@wsaw.com
Location Wausau, Wisconsin, United States
Facebook 5.5KTwitter 10.7KInstagram 13.3K Avg Length 16 min Format Short form Get Email Contact

14. Beer, Cheese & Murder

Beer, Cheese & Murder
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
A true crime podcast about Wisconsin from Wisconsin.
Host Erica Z.
Email ****@beercheeseandmurderpodcast.com
Location Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 11Instagram 115 Avg Length 82 min Format Long form Get Email Contact

15. Nightmare In Wisconsin: Taylor Shabusiness Trial

Nightmare In Wisconsin: Taylor Shabusiness Trial
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Host Tony Brueski
Producer/Network True Crime Today
Location Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 2.6/5Apple Reviews 11Twitter 3.4KInstagram 5.1K Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact

No results found

Reset Filters
Show 16 to 100

Wisconsin True Crime shows hosts and producers

Export full list with direct email contacts in a spreadsheet or csv file. Get Spreadsheet
Podcaster Name Email Role Podcast Link Podcast Episodes Gender Twitter Handle Location
Scott Wittman Host badgerbizarre.libsyn.com 58 Male @scottwittman WI, United States
Mickey Sanders Host badgerbizarre.libsyn.com 58 Male Appleton, WI, United States
Vanessa Grigoriadis Host podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-bambi-run/id1616022051 14 Female @vanessagrigor NY, United States
Gavin Schmitt Host milwaukee-mafia.captivate.fm 293 Male
Gina Barton Investigative Reporter/Host audioboom.com/channels/4655198-unsolved 82 Female @writerbarton
Dorothy Marcic Host wondery.com/shows/man-slaughter 8 Female New York City, NY, United States
Gavin Schmitt Host foxcitiesmm.com/podcast-episodes 192 Male
Eric Wulterkens Host foxcitiesmm.com/podcast-episodes 192 Appleton, WI, United States
Kassandra Sepeda Host forgottenwisconsincoldcases.podbean.com 27 @kassandrasepeda Wausau, WI, United States
Erica Z. Host beercheeseandmurderpodcast.com/blog 39 Female
True Crime Today Producer audioboom.com/channels/5112099-nightmare-in-wisconsin-taylor-shabusiness-trial 48
Tony Brueski Host audioboom.com/channels/5112099-nightmare-in-wisconsin-taylor-shabusiness-trial 48 @tonybpod
Load 13 to 1000+ Podcasters