15 Best Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts
Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts
Here are 15 Best Wisconsin True Crime Podcasts worth listening to in 2026.
Export Contact List1. Badger Bizarre
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
True crime, unsolved mysteries, paranormal tales and bizarre happenings in the state of Wisconsin.
Hosts Scott Wittman, Mickey Sanders
Email ****@att.net
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Recent Guests Charlotte Lamb, Otis Redding +1 more
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 49Facebook 1.8KTwitter 47 Avg Length 118 min Format Extended Get Email Contact Get access to full database of 2.7M podcastsCreate podcast lists, export in spreadsheet or CSV file with email contacts and start your podcast outreach in minutes.Sign Up for Free with Email Continue with Google
2. Run, Bambi, Run
Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
Laurie Bembenek was a Milwaukee police officer and Playboy Club bunny before being arrested for the murder of her husband's ex-wife, a crime she insisted she did not commit. Nicknamed 'Bambi Bembenek,' she became a tabloid fixation, a feminist cause célèbre and, after she escaped from prison, an American folk hero, though she was never exonerated...more Host Vanessa Grigoriadis
Producer/Network Apple TV / Campside Media
Email ****@mac.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 4.4/5Apple Reviews 1.7K Avg Length 24 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
3. Milwaukee Mafia
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
Did you know Milwaukee had a Mafia? Many people don't realize how powerful the Milwaukee Mafia was - especially during Frank Balistrieri's impressive 30-year reign! Gavin Schmitt has been researching and writing published works on the Milwaukee Mafia for over a decade, and is considered the top expert on the subject.Join Gavin Schmitt and Eric Wulterkens as Gavin takes you through stories of the Milwaukee Mafia, and related Wisconsin true crime. For more information, visit MilwaukeeMafia.commore Host Gavin Schmitt
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Recent Guests Sid Ceasar, John Balistreri +2 more
Apple Rating 4.3/5Apple Reviews 48Facebook 775 Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
4. Unsolved: A murder mystery podcast
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
More often than we'd like to believe, people get away with murder. In cold cases, cops have retired. Witnesses have died. Evidence has disappeared. Unsolved: A murder mystery podcast is a true crime podcast series powered by investigative journalism from USA TODAY and the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, guides listeners through these real-life cases, uncovering new clues along the way. The series features new unsolved cases and true crime cases each season...more Host Gina Barton
Producer/Network USA TODAY and Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Email ****@gannett.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 4/5Apple Reviews 930Facebook 10.5MTwitter 5.1MInstagram 3.8M Avg Length 23 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
5. MANslaughter
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
MANslaughter tells intertwining stories about how one gunshot on a cold Wisconsin night in 1970 dramatically changed multiple lives. A bullet brutally tore through decorated law enforcement veteran LaVerne Stordock. Decades later, his niece, Dorothy Marcic, transformed herself into an amateur detective in a quest for truth and closure about that night. At the center of Dorothy's investigation is Suzanne Brandon, LaVerne's second wife, who confessed to the shooting -- and who Dorothy believes completely escaped justice...more Host Dorothy Marcic
Producer/Network Wondery
Email ****@wondery.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 50k-250k
Apple Rating 3.3/5Apple Reviews 1.6KFacebook 165.4KTwitter 107.1KInstagram 196.2K Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
6. Cold Case: Frozen Tundra
Play Watch Video
Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Co-host Dr. Jordan Karsten is a university professor and anthropologist often asked to assist law enforcement in the excavation and identification of human remains. Matt Hiskes, the show's other host, is a communications and media professional with a passion for solving puzzles. In Cold Case: Frozen Tundra, the pair work with law enforcement, family members, and the community to take a fresh, in-depth look at unresolved cases in search of answers. Season 1 focuses on the 1983 disappearance of Starkie Swenson of Neenah, WI...more Producer/Network Dogfish Stingray Media
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 179 Avg Length 35 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
7. Severed Affair: The Gruesome Murder of Shad Thyrion
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Wisconsin is no stranger to high-profile cases and horrific murderers, from the notorious Jeffrey Dahmer to the perplexing Ed Gein. But on a cold night in February 2022, a new name was added to the list of Wisconsin's worst: Taylor Schabusiness. From the outset, the details of the case shocked even the most hardened detectives and traumatized young rookies. Using Law&Crime Network's gavel-to-gavel coverage, Severed Affair provides an in-depth narrative of the disturbing case. The Law&Crime original podcast uses exclusive audio and court footage to piece together the gruesome story.more Producer/Network Law&Crime
Email ****@lawandcrime.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 10k-50k
Apple Rating 3.6/5Apple Reviews 335Facebook 5.7MTwitter 141K Avg Length 30 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
8. Fox Cities Murder & Mayhem
Play
Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Wisconsin has had it's fair share of notorious criminals that have been in the spotlight over the years, but what about bizarre crimes and mayhem that have vanished over time? Join author Gavin Schmitt and Eric Wulterkens as they take you through stories of crimes that were once front page news. Gavin will share crimes from his book 'Fox Cities Murder & Mayhem' as well as those that have never been shared by him before.If you're a fan of true crime who is tired of hearing about the same murders over and over, then you'll definitely like this podcast...more Hosts Gavin Schmitt, Eric Wulterkens
Producer/Network Gavin Schmitt
Email ****@gmail.com
Location Appleton, Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.6/5Apple Reviews 7Facebook 775 Avg Length 38 min Format Medium form Video Podcast YouTube
Get Email Contact
9. My Cousin Augie
Play
Apple Spotify Episodes
In 1978, Milwaukee tavern owner Augie Palmisano was killed in a car bombing. Although many suspected crime boss Frank Balistrieri, the murder was never solved. 45 years later, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel investigative reporter Mary Spicuzza goes on a journey to find the truth.more Producer/Network Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
Email ****@gannett.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 1k-10k
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 25 Avg Length 27 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
10. True Crime Wisconsin
Play
Apple Episodes
True Crime Wisconsin, a new weekly podcast from WMTV 15 News, goes beyond the headlines to investigate the state's most haunting unsolved cases. Wisconsin has made national news for some high-profile crimes — but not every case gets that kind of attention. Some stories fade from the spotlight, and some are never solved.Each week, WMTV 15 News digs into a different case from across Wisconsin, talking with the detectives and investigators still working to find answers, and the people who may hold the missing piece of the puzzle...more Producer/Network WMTV
Email ****@wmtv15news.com
Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
11. Ope, it's Murder
Play
Apple Episodes
Midwest roots. Dark stories. Strong coffee. Two best friends uncovering Wisconsin and Midwest true crime, one cup at a time.
Producer/Network Lindsey and Libbie
Email ****@opeitsmurder.com
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 3 Avg Length 31 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
12. Dark Matter Moms
Play
Apple Episodes
Dark Matter Moms is a true crime podcast hosted by Sam and Sarah, two moms with a passion for uncovering the truth behind real criminal cases. With a special focus on Wisconsin crimes, we dig into court records, trial transcripts, police reports, and investigative documents to tell the stories behind the headlines. From murders and missing persons to courtroom twists and overlooked details, we explore the cases that continue to haunt communities while keeping victims and their families at the heart of every story.more Producer/Network Dark Matter Moms
Email ****@gmail.com
Apple Rating 5/5Apple Reviews 1 Avg Length 53 min Format Long form Get Email Contact
13. Wisconsin Cold Cases Podcast
Play
Website Spotify YouTube Episodes
Every month, join WSAW's Kassandra Sepeda as she takes a deeper, investigative look into the often forgotten cold cases and missing people in central Wisconsin.
Host Kassandra Sepeda
Email ****@wsaw.com
Location Wausau, Wisconsin, United States
Facebook 5.5KTwitter 10.7KInstagram 13.3K Avg Length 16 min Format Short form Get Email Contact
14. Beer, Cheese & Murder
Play
Website Apple Spotify Episodes
A true crime podcast about Wisconsin from Wisconsin.
Host Erica Z.
Email ****@beercheeseandmurderpodcast.com
Location Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 4.5/5Apple Reviews 11Instagram 115 Avg Length 82 min Format Long form Get Email Contact
15. Nightmare In Wisconsin: Taylor Shabusiness Trial
Play
Website Apple Spotify YouTube Episodes
Taylor Schabusiness, a 24-year-old from Green Bay, Wisconsin, stands accused of charges as horrific as they are complex. She is facing the grave charge of first-degree intentional homicide, suspected of the brutal strangulation of Shad Thyrion. Furthermore, she is accused of mutilating a corpse, alleged to have dismembered Thyrion's body in a chilling act following his death. Finally, Schabusiness is charged with third-degree sexual assault, with allegations of having engaged in sexual abuse with Thyrion's lifeless body...more Host Tony Brueski
Producer/Network True Crime Today
Location Wisconsin, United States
Estimated Monthly Listeners 100-1k
Apple Rating 2.6/5Apple Reviews 11Twitter 3.4KInstagram 5.1K Avg Length 34 min Format Medium form Get Email Contact
No results found
Reset FiltersWisconsin True Crime shows hosts and producers
| Podcaster Name | Role | Podcast Link | Podcast Episodes | Gender | Twitter Handle | Location | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scott Wittman | Host | badgerbizarre.libsyn.com | 58 | Male | @scottwittman | WI, United States | |
| Mickey Sanders | Host | badgerbizarre.libsyn.com | 58 | Male | Appleton, WI, United States | ||
| Vanessa Grigoriadis | Host | podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-bambi-run/id1616022051 | 14 | Female | @vanessagrigor | NY, United States | |
| Gavin Schmitt | Host | milwaukee-mafia.captivate.fm | 293 | Male | |||
| Gina Barton | Investigative Reporter/Host | audioboom.com/channels/4655198-unsolved | 82 | Female | @writerbarton | ||
| Dorothy Marcic | Host | wondery.com/shows/man-slaughter | 8 | Female | New York City, NY, United States | ||
| Gavin Schmitt | Host | foxcitiesmm.com/podcast-episodes | 192 | Male | |||
| Eric Wulterkens | Host | foxcitiesmm.com/podcast-episodes | 192 | Appleton, WI, United States | |||
| Kassandra Sepeda | Host | forgottenwisconsincoldcases.podbean.com | 27 | @kassandrasepeda | Wausau, WI, United States | ||
| Erica Z. | Host | beercheeseandmurderpodcast.com/blog | 39 | Female | |||
| True Crime Today | Producer | audioboom.com/channels/5112099-nightmare-in-wisconsin-taylor-shabusiness-trial | 48 | ||||
| Tony Brueski | Host | audioboom.com/channels/5112099-nightmare-in-wisconsin-taylor-shabusiness-trial | 48 | @tonybpod |